I see a lot of different answers, all from imams.
Some say. "No, all instruments and music are forbidden. Period."
Some say. "No, all instruments except for tambourine/duff at weddings are forbidden."
Some say. "Yes, but it must be strictly instrumental, no singing accompanied with it."
Some say "Yes, but if there is singing, the lyrics must be neutral or good"
Some say "Yes, but only within the confines within one's home, no public playing is allowed"
Some say. "Yes 100%, if music and specifically instruments were such a grave matter then the Qur'an surely would have mentioned them in a clear-cut verse."
What is the right answer? Thanks and God bless.
And my second question is: if your answer is "yes" what do you make of the oft-cited "from among my ummah there will be people who make wine/silk/instruments permissible" hadith that seems to be a strong hadith in Sahih?
[link] [comments]
from Islam https://ift.tt/2GyEznd
No comments:
Post a Comment